Colton Underwood, 32

Season 23

1

Andy Baldwin, 47

Season 10

2

Juan Pablo Galavis, 43

Season 18

3

Sean Lowe, 41

Season 17

4

Ben Higgins, 35

Season 20

5

Arie Luyendyk Jr., 43

Season 22

6

Travis Stork, 52

Season 8

7

Nick Viall, 44

Season 21

8

Charlie O'Connell, 49

Season 7

9

Chris Soules, 43

Season 19

10

Andrew Firestone, 49

Season 3

11

Aaron Buerge, 50

Season 2

12