Evan Peters, 37

Kit Walker

1

Adam Levine, 45

Leo Morrison

2

Sarah Paulson, 49

Lana Winters

3

James Cromwell, 84

Dr. Arthur Arden

4

Mark Consuelos, 53

Spivey

5

Lily Rabe, 42

Sister Mary Eunice McKee

6

Jessica Lange, 75

Sister Jude Martin

7

Jenna Dewan, 43

Teresa Morrison

8

Dylan McDermott, 63

Johnny Morgan

9

Frances Conroy, 71

Shachath 'The Angel of Death'

10

Zachary Quinto, 47

Dr. Oliver Thredson

11

Clea Duvall, 47

Wendy Peyser

12